Tom Dunman - Trainer and Coach

View Original

Most of us have unconscious biases we're not even aware of, leading us to making judgments without realising it. I explore how a little self-awareness can support us in being more open-minded.

Unconscious bias refers to the automatic, mental shortcuts that our brains use to process and make sense of information. These biases are based on our own experiences, cultural upbringing, and societal messages, and they can affect our decision-making and behavior in subtle and often unintended ways. While unconscious bias can occur in any aspect of life, it can be particularly relevant in the workplace, where it can impact things like hiring, promotion, and performance evaluations.

One of the key challenges of unconscious bias is that it operates outside of our conscious awareness. We may not even realize that we are making biased decisions or behaving in biased ways. This can make it difficult to identify and address unconscious bias, but it is important to try, as unconscious bias can have a significant impact on individuals and organizations.

There are many different types of unconscious bias, including:

  • Confirmation bias: This refers to the tendency to search for and interpret information in a way that confirms our preexisting beliefs. For example, if we have a positive view of a particular candidate for a job, we may be more likely to overlook their flaws and focus on their strengths.

  • Stereotyping: This refers to the tendency to make assumptions about people based on their group membership (e.g., race, gender, age, etc.). For example, we may assume that a woman is more nurturing or that an older worker is less tech-savvy.

  • Affinity bias: This refers to the tendency to favor people who are similar to us. For example, we may be more likely to hire or promote someone who went to the same college or who shares our hobbies.

  • In-group/out-group bias: This refers to the tendency to favor our own group (the in-group) over other groups (the out-group). For example, we may be more likely to trust or support someone who works in the same department as us over someone who works in a different department.

So how can we overcome unconscious bias in the workplace? Here are a few strategies that can help:

  1. Educate yourself: One of the first steps in overcoming unconscious bias is to become aware of your own biases. This can be challenging, as unconscious bias operates outside of our conscious awareness. However, there are resources available to help, such as online Implicit Association Tests (IATs) that measure unconscious biases.

  2. Implement structured decision-making processes: Structured decision-making processes, such as checklists and decision matrices, can help to minimize the impact of unconscious bias by ensuring that all relevant factors are considered.

  3. Diversify your network: Expanding your network to include people from diverse backgrounds can help to expose you to a wider range of perspectives and experiences, which can help to reduce the impact of unconscious bias.

  4. Practice mindfulness: Being mindful of your own thoughts and behaviors can help to reduce the impact of unconscious bias. This can involve taking a moment to pause and consider your assumptions and motivations before making a decision or taking action.

  5. Promote diversity and inclusion: Creating a diverse and inclusive work environment can help to reduce the impact of unconscious bias by providing multiple perspectives and experiences. This can involve things like implementing diversity and inclusion training, establishing employee resource groups, and implementing fair and inclusive policies and practices.

Now let's consider some real-world examples of unconscious bias playing out in the workplace.

One common example of unconscious bias is the gender pay gap. Research has shown that women are often paid less than men for doing the same job, even when controlling for factors like education and experience. This pay gap can be the result of many factors, including unconscious bias. For example a hiring manager may have an unconscious bias that men are more qualified or more committed to their work, leading them to offer a higher salary to a male candidate over a female candidate with similar qualifications. This unconscious bias can perpetuate the gender pay gap and lead to discrimination against women in the workplace.

Another example of unconscious bias in the workplace is the "glass ceiling," or the invisible barrier that can prevent women and minorities from advancing to top leadership positions. This unconscious bias can occur when decision-makers have an unconscious preference for candidates who are similar to themselves (affinity bias) or when they are more likely to trust and support candidates from their own group (in-group bias). This can lead to a lack of diversity at the top levels of an organization and perpetuate discrimination against underrepresented groups.

Unconscious bias can also impact the performance evaluations of employees. For example, a manager may have an unconscious bias that certain groups of employees (e.g., those who are similar to themselves, those who are part of their in-group) are more capable or more likely to succeed, leading them to give higher ratings and more opportunities to those employees. This can perpetuate a cycle of discrimination and create a disadvantage for employees who are not part of the favored group.

Overall, unconscious bias is a complex and often unconscious phenomenon that can have a significant impact on individuals and organizations. By educating ourselves, implementing structured decision-making processes, diversifying our networks, practicing mindfulness, and promoting diversity and inclusion, we can work to overcome unconscious bias and create a more equitable and inclusive workplace. One important aspect of unconscious bias that I didn't mention in my previous response is the role that societal messages and cultural conditioning can play in shaping our biases. These messages can be explicit, such as overt discrimination or prejudice, but they can also be more subtle, such as media portrayals or cultural norms.

For example, research has shown that women and minorities are often underrepresented in media, leading to a lack of role models and representation for these groups. This can contribute to unconscious bias by reinforcing stereotypes and limiting the range of experiences and perspectives that people are exposed to.

Cultural conditioning can also play a role in shaping our unconscious biases. For example, certain cultures may place a higher value on certain traits or characteristics, leading to an unconscious bias in favor of those traits. For example, in some cultures, assertiveness and aggression may be valued more highly than collaboration and cooperation, leading to an unconscious bias against those who exhibit more collaborative or cooperative behavior.

Another important aspect of unconscious bias is the role that it can play in perpetuating inequality and injustice. Unconscious biases can lead to discrimination and disadvantage for certain groups, such as women, minorities, and people with disabilities. This can have significant impacts on individuals and organizations, leading to a lack of diversity, lower productivity, and missed opportunities.

To address these issues, it is important for individuals and organizations to actively work to identify and overcome their unconscious biases. This can involve things like educating ourselves, implementing structured decision-making processes, and promoting diversity and inclusion. It can also involve challenging societal messages and cultural conditioning that contribute to unconscious bias. By taking these steps, we can work to create a more equitable and inclusive society.